A few months back, there's an outburst / uproar of art community on the rise of ai art - on how it's non-ethical, damaging the art industry, and regression to art; because how it collects data from original artists (even copyrighted) without consent, and that the end product is a mash-up of styles of existing artworks instead of going thru meaningful thought processes.
is it fun? Yes.
But when one uses it to generate business at the expenses of original artists, then it is not.
Already there's alot brouhaha and disclaimer from developers absolving themselves from legal implications etc.
U can follow thru some discourse here;
And then we have this;
Yes. There's a new ai that generates your dream room, which is roomgpt.
And do i personally feel threatened by it?
But this is an app that generates your dream room. DREAM ROOM. Surely interior designers / architects are sweating because of this?
Err no. And whoever thought of this;-
a) never hired a proper design consultant / interior designer / architect before
b) doesnt have an inkling on how consultant's work.
Err no. And whoever thought of this;-
a) never hired a proper design consultant / interior designer / architect before
b) doesnt have an inkling on how consultant's work.
c) is designers that rely solely on pinterest to sell their design ideas.
I dont blame the masses for (b); even our family think our job is scribble scribble on paper then magically pretty render images comes out. "Magic".
Lets run thru the app abit;
1. User friendly interface. Click theme, click type of room, upload your room picture - voila!
2. Theme; probably they'll upgrade it later on - limited, general. But there's like a tons of theme/style son. If client wants Gundam theme or some aviation dope, then how?
3. Room type; again, maybe improvement in the future. But like how bout cigar rooms? Musollah? Fancy some S&M room? (this app developer ought to hire me).
4. Render images. Yeaaay! now we dont have to hire interior designers anymore. Just shove this to contractor and let them build it based on it. (good luck son).
2. Theme; probably they'll upgrade it later on - limited, general. But there's like a tons of theme/style son. If client wants Gundam theme or some aviation dope, then how?
3. Room type; again, maybe improvement in the future. But like how bout cigar rooms? Musollah? Fancy some S&M room? (this app developer ought to hire me).
4. Render images. Yeaaay! now we dont have to hire interior designers anymore. Just shove this to contractor and let them build it based on it. (good luck son).
Should us consultants be IMMEDIATELY afraid?
a) Best this app can do is generate images. For REFERENCE. Definitely not fit to issue for construction.
b) In our line of work, this comes during schematic stage, which is like 15% of overall consultant's fee (if in Malaysia, per Architect's Act Scale of Minimum Fee). And this render doesnt cover the full schematic phase works; - there's like site visit / investigation, preconsult with local authorities, etc.
c) The resulted image is generated from photos users uploaded. Will it stay consistent if it's from different angle? How does it tally/works/vibes with the rest of the house? What if u want to maintained existing built-in or appliances? Getting tricky now isnt it?
d) Simply generated images with provided existing photos is not the same as understanding the end user's briefing. Would one prefer less furniture? Would one want more consideration for their pets? Feng shui? Some nostalgic moments to be captured? This only comes with thorough discussion with the client instead of 'click click magic'.
e) Early warning - please, please, please dont just shoved images to your contractors and asks them to build it "as per images". They need drawings; proper measurements and details. And specs and budgets.
f) U know the important part U got from GOOD consultants that U can't get from machines and apps? Design Thought Process; there's meaning in every single line / detail / placement of the overall design instead of simply mashing up images from pinterest. Legally - Professional endorsement and RESPONSIBILITY.
Conclussion;
This app is fun; it kickstarts the idea of u wanting to refurbish your room.
But its wayyyyy off to provide meaningful design discourse - more like another pinterest exercise, but with little bit accuracy to match your room's photo.
On another note, there's already startups doing massing and floorplan studies using AI.
So are architects / interior designer / design consultants irrelevant in this ever changing technology?
In my varsity days i recalled one of my lecturers saying along the line; "master sketchup (a software) instead of letting it mastering you". We will have to adapt to new technologies and tools. Always have, always been, always will be.
As the argument with ai arts, for me personally the process is what makes the design built matter more. Communicating with clients, understanding the need and briefs, painstakingly investigating / doing design iterations to make the built design meaningful, emotionally aesthetic and meeting all the variables along the way - that in itself is why this profession exists (and satisfying).
Unless you're building for numbers and profits with no regards to humane side, then yeah, heil skynet!
d) Simply generated images with provided existing photos is not the same as understanding the end user's briefing. Would one prefer less furniture? Would one want more consideration for their pets? Feng shui? Some nostalgic moments to be captured? This only comes with thorough discussion with the client instead of 'click click magic'.
e) Early warning - please, please, please dont just shoved images to your contractors and asks them to build it "as per images". They need drawings; proper measurements and details. And specs and budgets.
f) U know the important part U got from GOOD consultants that U can't get from machines and apps? Design Thought Process; there's meaning in every single line / detail / placement of the overall design instead of simply mashing up images from pinterest. Legally - Professional endorsement and RESPONSIBILITY.
Conclussion;
This app is fun; it kickstarts the idea of u wanting to refurbish your room.
But its wayyyyy off to provide meaningful design discourse - more like another pinterest exercise, but with little bit accuracy to match your room's photo.
On another note, there's already startups doing massing and floorplan studies using AI.
So are architects / interior designer / design consultants irrelevant in this ever changing technology?
In my varsity days i recalled one of my lecturers saying along the line; "master sketchup (a software) instead of letting it mastering you". We will have to adapt to new technologies and tools. Always have, always been, always will be.
As the argument with ai arts, for me personally the process is what makes the design built matter more. Communicating with clients, understanding the need and briefs, painstakingly investigating / doing design iterations to make the built design meaningful, emotionally aesthetic and meeting all the variables along the way - that in itself is why this profession exists (and satisfying).
Unless you're building for numbers and profits with no regards to humane side, then yeah, heil skynet!
Disclaimer; personal opinion. Just blurting it out with all this brouhaha of doomsday of creative community imposed on us.
